What are a law firm’s duties when client information goes into an AI tool?
Take reasonable steps before client information goes into AI. Be able to show them.
Under the rule, your lawyers must make reasonable efforts to protect everything about a client’s matter, whether or not the client marked it confidential. The aim is to stop disclosure by accident or without permission, and access by anyone who isn’t allowed to see it. Sending that information to an AI provider your firm has no agreement with is the unauthorized disclosure the rule asks lawyers to prevent. Each state adopts its own version of the rule, and your state’s text is the one that binds your lawyers. Keep a record of which AI tools are approved, what may go into each, who reviewed the vendor’s terms, and that your lawyers were trained.
ABA Model Rule 1.6(c) requires a lawyer to make reasonable efforts to prevent the inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure of, or unauthorized access to, information relating to the representation of a client.
The duty reaches all information relating to the representation, whatever its source, not only what a client marked confidential. Sending that information to an AI provider the firm has no agreement with is the unauthorized disclosure the rule asks the lawyer to prevent.
The Model Rules are models. Each state adopts its own version of Rule 1.6, and the state’s text is the one that binds the lawyer.
What counts as reasonable efforts
Rule 1.6(c) doesn’t name a technology. It asks whether the lawyer took reasonable steps, given the circumstances and how sensitive the information is. In practice, your firm can show reasonable efforts when it can point to:
- which tools are approved
- what data may go into each
- who reviewed the vendor’s terms
- that the lawyers were trained
If your firm can’t show those four things, it has no evidence that it made reasonable efforts.
Competence and supervision apply too
The first is competence. Comment 8 to Model Rule 1.1 tells lawyers to keep abreast of the benefits and risks associated with relevant technology. With an AI tool, that includes knowing what it does with whatever is typed into it.
Then there’s supervision. Model Rule 5.3 covers nonlawyer assistance, including services from outside the firm, so someone at your firm has to be responsible for reviewing the AI vendor.
Can using an AI tool waive privilege?
Rule 1.6 governs the lawyer. The attorney-client privilege governs the case, and voluntarily disclosing a privileged communication to a third party outside the privilege generally risks waiving it. The law is unsettled on whether an AI provider bound by confidentiality terms counts as that kind of third party. Privileged material is the category to keep inside an AI setup your firm controls, because a discipline problem can be fixed and a waived privilege can’t.
Sourcing note. We read Rule 1.6(c) above against the ABA’s published Model Rules. The Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility issued ABA Formal Opinion 512, on generative AI, on July 29, 2024. It addresses generative AI under Rules 1.1, 1.6, 1.4, 1.5, 5.1, 5.3, 3.1 and 3.3, a list we confirmed against the ABA’s own announcement. Its conclusion on informed consent before client information goes into a self-learning tool is widely reported. We haven’t yet read that conclusion against the opinion itself, so this page doesn’t state it as a finding.
Related questions
Does a lawyer need client consent before using AI on a matter?+
This page doesn’t answer that. ABA Formal Opinion 512 is widely reported to address it, but we haven’t read its conclusion against the opinion itself. Read the opinion and your state’s ethics guidance before you rely on a general answer.
Is a firm-controlled AI deployment enough on its own?+
No, though it’s the strongest option short of keeping the material on the device. The vendor is bound by contract, and the data stays under your firm’s own rules and oversight. For reasonable efforts under Rule 1.6(c), you still need a written review of the vendor’s terms, a policy on what may go into each tool, and training for your lawyers.
Do the Model Rules bind my firm directly?+
No, they’re models. The rule that governs is the one your own state adopted, and states differ in both the rule text and the comments.
Model Rule 1.6 is one duty among several that reach a firm holding confidential client material. The map shows the rest, and which control satisfies each one.
Get a one-page estimateRun the law-firm rulesetSee the obligation mapGeneral reference, not legal or tax advice. Every figure and deadline on this page was read against the primary source. Claremont Security performs assessments and writes documentation. Formal sign-offs belong to licensed firms.
