The short answer
Copilot shows staff what they could already open. Fix who can open what first.
Microsoft 365 Copilot doesn't give anyone new access. It answers each person only from what that person is already allowed to open, and in most small firms that's far more than anyone meant. File access built up over the years and nobody cleaned it up, so Copilot makes those files easy to find. Before you turn it on, review who can open what, fix the obvious problems and write down what you did. For a firm of ten to twenty-five people, that's a few days' work.
The question managing partners ask us most about Microsoft 365 Copilot is whether it's safe to turn on. We usually answer with another one: what can each person on your staff open today? Once you know that, you know what Copilot will show them.
What Copilot can open
Copilot answers each person using only what that person is already allowed to open. It doesn't hand anyone new access; it follows your firm's access settings exactly as they stand today.
That would be reassuring if someone had designed those settings. In most small firms nobody did, and access simply built up over the years. So Copilot doesn't create a new leak. It makes an old one easy to find. The same is true of any assistant that reads your files as the signed-in person, Claude's Microsoft 365 connector included.
Picture a partner compensation spreadsheet saved in a shared folder. Eleven people could open it, but nobody ever did, because nobody knew it was there. The only thing keeping it private was that it was hard to find.
Copilot removes that. Someone asks a plain question and gets an answer drawn from the spreadsheet. They were always allowed to open it; nobody expected them to come across it. Nothing in the system broke, which is why it's so awkward to explain afterward.
How staff end up with more access than they need
In small firms, almost all of it comes from four ordinary habits, and none of them involves anyone being careless.
The move to the cloud. Someone moved the old file server into SharePoint or OneDrive over a weekend. The folders came across as they were, but the restrictions on them often didn't, because keeping them wasn't anyone's job.
"Anyone with the link" sharing. If nobody ever tightened this default, every link shared in the last four years still works for whoever holds it, and nobody has a list of those links.
Whole-folder access. Someone needed one document, so they were given the whole folder, and the folder has kept growing since.
Too many administrators. Not everyone on staff holds administrator rights, but everyone who was once senior, set up a laptop or fixed something on a Sunday in filing season does.
If you hand out Copilot licenses in a firm like that, something will come up sooner or later. You won't get to choose what comes up first, or who is in the room when it does.
Five checks before you turn it on
None of this needs a project plan or new software. For a firm your size the review takes a few days, and you don't need to buy anything.
1. Match access to who works here now. Check who can open what against this week's staff list rather than the org chart. The usual find is people who have left. Their accounts were kept open for the handover and never lost any access.
2. Find the "anyone with the link" shares. Give each one an expiry date or remove it, then change the default so new links don't pile up the same way.
3. Lock down the files that should never be open to everyone. That means payroll and pay, partner and firm finances, anything under its own confidentiality agreement, and HR matters. In most firms these sit alongside everything else, kept apart only by a folder name.
4. Limit administrator rights to the people who need them. Some people hold admin rights their job doesn't need. Taking them back won't be popular, but it's the one thing an insurer and an examiner will both ask about, each in their own words.
5. Decide what Copilot is allowed to read. A general assistant that can search everything a person can open carries a different risk from a focused one that reads a single document library (one shared set of files). Make that choice when you set Copilot up, because it's much harder to change once staff have built habits around it.
Do the first four before anyone gets a license. Running the review after staff are already using Copilot, and finding things, is a lot more uncomfortable.
Which Copilot your staff are using
Several products carry the Copilot name, and they don't come with the same promises.
The business version is Microsoft 365 Copilot, on a commercial license in your firm's Microsoft 365. It comes with Microsoft's enterprise data protection commitments, which are contract terms set out in the Microsoft Data Protection Addendum and the Product Terms. The consumer versions don't. Microsoft Copilot on a personal account is the free one, and Microsoft no longer sells Copilot Pro; it points those subscribers to Microsoft 365 Premium.
On screen they look almost the same, but for a firm holding client tax returns the contract behind each one is very different. Your staff could be "using Copilot" in three places at once, under three different sets of terms, with no record of which is which. A list of which Copilot each person uses is the place to start, and it usually takes an afternoon.
Write the review down
Fixing the access is the easier part. What pays off later is a record of it: what you checked, on what date, which role did it, what you found and what you changed. Keep the same kind of record for the list of Copilot versions and for the decision about what Copilot may read.
For a firm holding customer information, two of those steps are part of the FTC Safeguards Rule at 16 CFR 314.4(c). One is controlling who can get to that information, and the other is reviewing that access from time to time. Separately, in June 2026 the IRS Office of Professional Responsibility asked firms to document their AI procedures. Correct settings on their own can't show that access is controlled and reviewed, or that AI procedures are documented. Correct settings with a dated record of the last review can.
A firm that fixed its access and kept no record has done the work and kept none of the value. It will do the work again the next time someone asks.
The house rule · Claremont SecuritySo run the review first, write it down as you go, and turn Copilot on after that. It's a few days of work whenever you do it. Doing it first means you aren't doing it later, with people watching.
Related questions
Does Microsoft 365 Copilot widen access to firm data?+
No. It answers each person only from what that person is already allowed to open. What changes is how easy things are to find: a document eleven people could open, but nobody could find, now comes back from a plain question.
Where does the extra access come from?+
In small firms, four ordinary habits cause most of it, and none of them is carelessness. A file server was moved into SharePoint or OneDrive over a weekend, and the folders came across while the restrictions often didn't. "Anyone with the link" sharing was never tightened, so every link shared in the last four years still works. Someone who needed one document was given the whole folder. And administrator rights are held by everyone who was once senior, set up a laptop or fixed something on a Sunday.
What should a firm check before giving staff Copilot licenses?+
Five things. Match access to this week's staff list. Find every "anyone with the link" share and set an expiry or remove it, then change the default. Lock down payroll and pay, partner and firm finances, anything under its own confidentiality agreement, and HR matters. Limit administrator rights to the people who need them. Decide what Copilot is allowed to read. Do the first four before anyone gets a license.
Does every version of Copilot come with the same data protection?+
No. Microsoft's enterprise data protection commitments come with Microsoft 365 Copilot on a commercial license in the firm's Microsoft 365, under the Microsoft Data Protection Addendum and the Product Terms. The consumer versions don't carry them. Microsoft Copilot on a personal account is free, and Microsoft no longer sells Copilot Pro; it points those subscribers to Microsoft 365 Premium.
Why write the review down?+
Because correct settings don't show, by themselves, that anyone reviewed access, or when. For a firm holding customer information, controlling and reviewing access is part of the FTC Safeguards Rule at 16 CFR 314.4(c). In June 2026 the IRS Office of Professional Responsibility asked firms to document their AI procedures. A dated record of the last review can show both.
Claremont Security helps regulated firms get more done with AI on client work, with the setup and the record to show for it, whichever tool the firm uses. To see where your firm stands, the AI Readiness Check is free and needs no account: claremontsecurity.com/readiness
Get a one-page estimate for your firm: what the work would take and what it’s worth, from your own numbers. No charge.
claremontsecurity.com/insights/copilot-does-not-leak-it-reveals
